The Great Celebrity Bake Off Traumatized John Lithgow

-Welcome back. We love having you here. You’re one of my all-time favorites. I love you. My wife loves you. My babies love you. My dog loves you — Gary. -The subject of one of my portraits, your dog. -That’s — exactly. You painted a beautiful painting of Gary, and I have it — I have that hanging on my wall. I see you every day. -Wonderful to be back, Jimmy. -You’re like a Jack of all trades. You do all these amazing things. You’re a great actor. You’re a poet.

You’re an author. And one thing I did not know is that you are a good baker. -Oh, my God. -Yes. Yes. You know what I’m about to discuss. -I am a mediocre baker. But I became something of a celebrity in England… -Yes. I just… Oh, I can’t — I’m so excited to bring this up. I can tell you’re very excited about it. What was this? -I was a guest contestant on “The Great British Bake Off.” -I love that show! -Yeah, I — It’s a wonderful show. It’s hugely, hugely popular in England. They asked me to come over and do it. And I foolishly said, “I’d love to.” And it was one of the great traumas of my life.

-To be honest, I think you did okay. -Well, you know, there are three challenges, and I did okay in the two that I could practice beforehand. But then, they throw you this technical challenge where you don’t — they present you with what you have to do with a very rudimentary recipe. And you just have to do it with you own — -And you brain just melts? -It was — It was a horrifying experience. It was a Swiss — It was a Swiss roll. I’d never even heard of a Swiss roll. -Right now — Little Debbie is in shock, right now. She is like, “What?” Now, the Swiss roll is this. -Yeah. That’s a good Swiss roll. -That’s a beautiful Swiss roll. -Yeah. -Yeah, now, here’s what — -Orange and black, and stripes, and the roll is perfect.

-Here’s what you made. -It looks like a… -Oh, my God. -Absolutely horrible. It looks like a tiger’s turd. -What did the judges say? What did they… -Uh, Prue — Well, Prue, one of the judges — very distinguished English lady — her judgement was, “Not sellable in any cake shop.” I think you came pretty close, man. -Well… -No, I don’t. No, I — No, I don’t. I don’t really, though. -And then, I — And in the middle of the night on the night that I did it, I woke up in the middle of the night, and realized, “Wait, a minute. I left out the Goddamn flour.” -Flour? Flour? -Try making a Swiss roll without flour. So, this is really more advanced, if you want to get real technical.

-Yeah. -He made this without flour, you guys. So, come on. You should get bonus points. Well, it probably tasted great. .

John Lithgow shares his horrifying experience baking on a celebrity version of The Great British Bake Off and the key ingredient he missed while making a Swiss roll.

Subscribe NOW to The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon:

Watch The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon Weeknights 11:35/10:35c
Get more Jimmy Fallon:
Follow Jimmy:
Like Jimmy:

Get more The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon:
Follow The Tonight Show:
Like The Tonight Show:
The Tonight Show Tumblr:

Get more NBC:
NBC YouTube:
Like NBC:
Follow NBC:
NBC Tumblr:
NBC Google+:

The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon features hilarious highlights from the show including: comedy sketches, music parodies, celebrity interviews, ridiculous games, and, of course, Jimmy’s Thank You Notes and hashtags! You’ll also find behind the scenes videos and other great web exclusives.

The Great Celebrity Bake Off Traumatized John Lithgow